Is assertive community treatment coercive?
نویسندگان
چکیده
Background Assertive community treatment (ACT) has become one of the cornerstones of care for people with serious mental illnesses. ACT is usually conceptualized as incorporating a multidisciplinary team approach, active and persistent attempts to engage clients, direct provision of comprehensive health and social care, and in-vivo and out-of-hours working. In addition, the service is ongoing, not time-limited, and has a low practitioner-to-client ratio (usually 1:10). However, ACT is not without its critics, many of them focused on the use of "coercive" techniques with ACT patients [1,2]. At one end of the spectrum are those opponents of ACT who contend, "ACT is largely a euphemistic label for coercion." Despite substantial interest in the coercive aspects of ACT, no studies have focused specifically on understanding the phenomenology of the use and experience of leverage in ACT.
منابع مشابه
Pressure and perceived coerciveness in an assertive community treatment program: an exploratory study
Background Limited evidence suggests that Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) teams may in some cases be unnecessarily coercive. The study aimed to adapt or develop measures of client-perceived coerciveness, and of actual pressure or coercion, in an ACT setting. It also aimed to examine the association between these two constructs, as well as their associations with client sociodemographic and ...
متن کاملPsychiatry and the law: do the fields agree in their views on coercive treatment?
Coercion is an element of some treatments in psychiatry and it is contemplated in legislation, which often dictates parameters for involuntary admissions and use of restrictive treatments. A trend in the past years has been to widen the parameters required for commitment, thus extending coercive elements of psychiatric treatments to less immediate situations and into the community as in asserti...
متن کاملPERSPECTIVES Patient Experiences of Autonomy and Coercion While Receiving Legal Leverage in Forensic Assertive Community Treatment
Legal leverage is broadly defined as the use of legal authority to promote treatment adherence. It is widely utilized withinmental health courts, drug courts, mandated outpatient treatment programs, and other intervention strategies for individuals with mental illness or chemical dependency who have contact with the criminal justice system. Nonetheless, the ethics of using legal authority to pr...
متن کاملA comparison of experts' perspectives on assertive community treatment and intensive case management.
This study compared experts' views on the critical ingredients of assertive community treatment and intensive case management. Twenty experts on assertive community treatment and 22 experts on intensive case management rated the importance of 40 elements common to each treatment approach. The assertive community treatment experts gave higher importance ratings than the intensive case management...
متن کاملEnhancing the effectiveness of an assertive outreach team : case study
introduced assertive community treatment (assertive outreach) teams in 1999 as part of provision of comprehensive services for the promotion and treatment of mental health. A Cochrane review in 1998 concluded that assertive community treatment was a clinically effective approach to managing the care of people with a severe mental illness in the community. Over the years, researchers have debate...
متن کامل